Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer has declined to commit to ending the current freeze on income tax and National Insurance (NI) thresholds, a policy that has pushed millions of taxpayers into higher tax brackets. The freeze, initiated under the Conservative government, is scheduled to conclude in April 2028, but uncertainty looms over whether it could be extended, sparking debate about the future direction of the UK’s tax policy.
Tax Threshold Freeze: Impact and Controversy
Since the financial year 2021/22, income tax and NI thresholds the income levels at which individuals begin paying tax or move into higher tax bands have been frozen. Normally, these thresholds increase annually in line with inflation, protecting earners from “fiscal drag,” where wage growth is eroded by rising tax liabilities. As a result of the freeze, pay increases have instead pushed a growing number of workers into higher tax brackets, effectively raising their tax burden without an official tax rate hike.
According to estimates, extending the freeze beyond 2028 could raise about £7 billion annually for the government, a substantial fiscal lever amid economic uncertainty. Chancellor Rachel Reeves, during Labour’s 2023 Budget speech, criticized the freeze as harmful to working people and vowed to return to indexation adjusting thresholds for inflation from 2028/29 onwards. However, in a tense exchange during Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs), Sir Keir stopped short of endorsing that policy commitment unequivocally.
When questioned by Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch on whether the government planned to lift the freeze, Starmer said, “No prime minister or chancellor is going to write a Budget in advance. We are absolutely fixed on our fiscal rules. We remain committed to them.” He emphasized adherence to Labour’s manifesto pledge not to increase income tax, NI, or VAT rates but did not explicitly guarantee reversing the thresholds freeze.
Fiscal Rules and Budget Constraints
Labour’s self-imposed fiscal framework centers on avoiding borrowing for day-to-day spending and reducing government debt relative to GDP by 2029/30. These rules are designed to inspire confidence among investors and financial markets but simultaneously restrict the government’s ability to introduce new spending without revenue increases.
Economic analysts caution that sticking rigidly to these targets may force the government to rely more on tax measures, such as continuing the threshold freeze, rather than discretionary spending. “The freeze is effectively a stealth tax increase,” explained Adam Marshall, Director General of the British Chambers of Commerce. “Extending it would provide necessary revenue but risks squeezing household incomes when many are already struggling with cost-of-living pressures.”
Wealth Tax Debate Heats Up
Beyond traditional tax policy, Badenoch also challenged Starmer on Labour’s attitude toward a proposed wealth tax, a contentious area within the party. Some on Labour’s left have advocated a 2% annual tax on assets exceeding £10 million, projecting revenues of £24 billion per year that could bolster public finances.
Critics argue such a tax risks capital flight and damaging the UK’s attractiveness for high-net-worth individuals. Badenoch asserted during PMQs, “This is a tax on all our constituents’ savings, their homes, their pensions — a tax on aspiration.” Starmer declined to endorse a wealth tax outright, stating that Labour had “stabilized the economy” and did not require lessons from the Conservatives on fiscal management.
Pressed further by Green Party MP Adrian Ramsay regarding tax fairness, Starmer remarked, “We can’t just tax our way to growth,” hinting at the party’s cautious approach towards aggressive taxation measures despite internal pressures.
Broader Economic and Political Implications
The debate over tax thresholds and potential new levies such as a wealth tax illustrates the complex balancing act the incoming government faces. Britain’s economy is experiencing slow growth, rising inflation, and increasing public debt levels following years of pandemic and energy crisis-related expenditures.
“Tax policy is at the heart of economic recovery,” said Professor Frances O’Grady, former TUC General Secretary. “Freezing thresholds helps government finances but hits middle-income earners hardest. Policymakers need to weigh fairness against fiscal necessity carefully.”
Labour’s hesitation to clarify its precise tax threshold plans reflects the challenges of reconciling progressive manifesto promises with harsh fiscal realities. The Treasury’s requirement for a credible fiscal plan that reassures markets adds to the pressure for pragmatic revenue generation.
Historical Context and Future Outlook
Historically, freezing income tax and NI thresholds has been used as a budgetary tool during periods of austerity or fiscal tightening. The Conservative government first introduced the freeze in 2021 as a response to ballooning public debt and inflationary pressures.
However, opponents contend that this approach effectively results in “stealth tax hikes,” disproportionately affecting working and middle-class households without increasing headline tax rates. Lifting the freeze would revert to protecting earnings from inflationary tax creep but would reduce government tax receipts by billions.
Looking ahead, the Labour Party’s forthcoming Budget promises to be closely scrutinized. Observers expect fiscal policy to remain tightly constrained by existing commitments, but ongoing debates over threshold adjustments, tax rates, and wealth taxes signal potential flashpoints.
The Office for Budget Responsibility has highlighted that maintaining the freeze could be one of the government’s most significant sources of non-tax revenue growth. Meanwhile, the Institute for Fiscal Studies urges transparency and targeted support for vulnerable households to mitigate regressive impacts.
Conclusion
Sir Keir Starmer’s reluctance to rule out extending the income tax and National Insurance threshold freeze underlines the pressing fiscal challenges confronting the UK government. While Labour pledges no rises in headline tax rates, uncertainty remains over measures that effectively increase taxation by pulling more earners into higher bands. Coupled with debates over a wealth tax and strict fiscal rules, these issues will be central to shaping the economic and political landscape in the coming years.
As the government prepares its next Budget, millions of taxpayers will be watching closely to see whether relief lies ahead or if the current freeze and its financial consequences will continue to bite deeper into household incomes.
For more detailed analysis and ongoing coverage of US labor markets, trade policies, UK government, finances and markets stay tuned to PGN Business Insider.
