The UK’s culture secretary, Lisa Nandy, has declared the BBC licence fee “unenforceable” and warned that “no options are off the table” as ministers prepare a comprehensive review of the broadcaster’s funding model later this year. Her comments, made in an interview with the Daily Telegraph, signal a potential shake-up of the £174.50 annual charge that provides around two-thirds of the BBC’s income.
Licence Fee at Breaking Point
“We recognise there are problems with the licence fee,” Nandy told the newspaper, noting that “fewer and fewer people are paying it.” The fee funds BBC television, radio, and online services, generating £3.7 billion in the last financial year, approximately 80% of which came directly from households. Yet compliance rates have slipped, and enforcement has drawn criticism for disproportionately targeting vulnerable groups.
Nandy highlighted concerns over past enforcement actions, particularly against women in single-adult households. “It’s unenforceable and, particularly, I’ve been very concerned about the way it’s been enforced in the past, with women, particularly vulnerable women, targeted for enforcement action,” she said. Two internal BBC reviews (2017 and 2023) attributed the gender disparity to societal factors, such as women being more likely to answer the door to TV-licensing officers.
Charter Review and Funding Options
The BBC’s Royal Charter expires in December 2027. Ahead of the mandated review, Nandy has already opened discussions with BBC executives about alternative funding mechanisms. While she ruled out complete reliance on general taxation, she said the government is “open to a different system” and will seek public input to design “a fairer, more sustainable model.”
“Nothing is off the table,” Nandy insisted. She suggested that a subscription model, tiered payments, or a wealth-adjusted levy could form part of future arrangements. Last month, BBC Chairman Richard Sharp proposed charging wealthier households more, but offered no firm figures.
A BBC spokesperson responded: “We welcome the chance to engage with government and our audiences on the next Charter. Our biggest-ever public consultation is underway, enabling viewers and listeners to shape a universal and independent BBC for the future.”
Why Change Is Urgent
Licence-fee non-payment has risen steadily, with an estimated 20% of households now evading the charge. The cost-of-living crisis has intensified resistance, as some viewers question paying for services they may no longer use. At the same time, streaming subscriptions and on-demand platforms have eroded the BBC’s exclusivity, reducing the perceived value of a universal fee.
Critics argue that the flat-rate licence fee is regressive: lower-income families contribute the same amount as wealthier households. In 2023, Nandy described the fee as “deeply regressive” and called for “radical and creative” thinking. The government’s review aims to address both fairness and the long-term viability of public broadcasting in the face of rapid technological change.
Stakeholder Views
- Consumer groups warn that any move to a subscription-based model risks excluding those unable to afford monthly payments, thereby undermining the BBC’s public-service remit.
- Industry analysts suggest that a hybrid model combining a reduced flat fee with optional subscription tiers could strike a balance between universal access and user choice.
- Opposition parties have accused the government of ideological hostility toward the BBC. A Labour spokesperson said: “The BBC is a global jewel. Reform should strengthen, not dismantle, its universal funding.”
What Happens Next
The Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) will launch a white paper in summer 2025, setting out possible funding scenarios and inviting formal responses. A public consultation, already the largest in BBC history, will run through the autumn. Parliamentary committees will then examine recommendations before the new Charter is finalised in 2027.
Throughout the process, Nandy has pledged transparency. “We want people’s voices to shape this,” she said. “Our goal is a system that is fair, sustainable, and preserves the BBC’s independence and universal reach.”
For more business News, check PGN Business Insider.
