A protracted legal dispute between the owners of a luxury penthouse on Park Lane, central London, and companies controlled by the late Mohamed Al Fayed and his family has entered its ninth year. The conflict, which initially surfaced over an agreement regarding a lift installation more than two decades ago, has since spiralled into allegations ranging from faulty refurbishments and leaky roofs to claims of deliberate noise disruption.
Dispute at Prime London Address Uncovered
The contested property is a penthouse apartment situated at Hyde Park Residence, 55 Park Lane, one of Mayfairโs most prestigious addresses overlooking Hyde Park. Owned by Alan and Rosaleen Hodson, the residence is part of a large apartment block adjacent to the Dorchester Hotel. The Hodsons purchased the penthouse in 2004, embarking on extensive renovations that included installing a new private lift.
Court documents reviewed by the BBC reveal that the ownership complexities and disagreements relating to the buildingโs maintenance are central to the ongoing legal wrangling. The dispute involves the Hodsons and Prestige Properties (PP), a company based in Liechtenstein and controlled by the Al Fayed family, which has owned and managed Hyde Park Residence since the 1980s.
Origins of the Conflict: Lift Installation and Leasehold Issues
The conflict began when Mr. Hodson sought to legalise his ownership of the lift by updating his lease, an action complicated by the intricate leasehold arrangements governing the building. While the freehold interest remains with the Grosvenor Estate an influential landholding entity in central London PP holds a leasehold interest granting them management rights for 110 years.
According to court papers, PP initially refused to recognise Mr. Hodsonโs ownership claim over the lift despite documented agreements. Adding to the complexity, the Hodsons undertook significant improvements without prior formal consent from the Grosvenor Estate, though retrospective permission was eventually granted in 2006 following payment of a ยฃ100,000 fee by Prestige Properties.
Escalation: Noise Complaints, Building Defects, and Refurbishment Disputes
By 2014, noise disturbances from two building lifts began to significantly trouble Mr. Hodson, prompting formal complaints. Representatives of the building agreed to restrict the use of one lift during night hours in 2015. However, relations deteriorated further in 2016 when PP demanded that Mr. Hodson contribute ยฃ80,000 towards earlier payments made to the Grosvenor Estate.
The following year, the Hodsons escalated matters by filing a High Court claim seeking redress for a series of grievances. Among the allegations were refusals by PP to grant permission for an extension Mr. Hodson wished to build despite initial encouragement and accusations that the building managers permitted the nighttime use of a noisy lift to deliberately disrupt the residentโs sleep. Mr. Hodsonโs legal team describes the liftโs nocturnal activity as โmalicious and deliberate,โ citing an incident when the lift was reportedly used 23 times between midnight and 2 a.m.
Moreover, the Hodsons have accused PP of poor maintenance work, alleging persistent leaks in the penthouseโs roof and consequential damage to the terraces. Recent court filings as of March 2025 state ongoing issues with leaking roofs, noise complaints, and unfinished communal areas following recent refurbishments.
Prestige Properties counters these claims, insisting that noise levels remain within โacceptable limitsโ and denying any intentional disturbances. While acknowledging some water leakage, PP asserts it has undertaken โall reasonable stepsโ to mitigate the problem. The company is also counterclaiming a combined total of ยฃ630,000 relating to ground rent, interest, and legal costs.
The Legacy of Mohamed Al Fayedโs Business Practices
Mohamed Al Fayed, who died in 2023 leaving an estate valued at approximately ยฃ1.7 billion, was known for his tenacity and litigious approach to business disputes. His ownership of properties such as Hyde Park Residence and 60 Park Lane formed significant parts of his real estate portfolio. The latter address was also the site of serious allegations concerning Fayedโs personal conduct; a BBC investigation in early 2024 interviewed 13 women accusing him of sexual assault, with four alleging rape.
In life, Al Fayed was famously combative, never shying from protracted court battles to defend his interests. The continuation of this drawn-out legal dispute after his death suggests that the familyโs approach to property management and contested claims remains unchanged.
Heini Wathen-Fayed, Mohamed Al Fayedโs widow and director of Hyde Park Residence Ltd which manages some of Hyde Park Residence apartments is among the key figures in the propertyโs current operations, linking the management to the family estate.
Hyde Park Residence Today: Prestige Meets Challenges
Hyde Park Residence enjoys a prime Mayfair location, with its penthouses offering panoramic views of Hyde Park and immediate proximity to several of Londonโs most exclusive hotels and landmarks. The buildingโs website touts โan atmosphere of warmth and calm with the best of London living,โ highlighting luxury and comfort.
Yet some critics and observers note a disconnect between these claims and the buildingโs present condition. BBC journalists report visible signs of wear such as peeling paint and a missing sign at the buildingโs entrance, which contrast sharply with the opulence often associated with Park Lane properties. In 2003, the Mail on Sunday described the buildingโs marble foyer as โsensationalโ suggesting a bygone era of greater upkeep.
Currently, a four-bedroom apartment in Hyde Park Residence is listed for sale at ยฃ8.5 million, underscoring the valuable nature of the asset despite ongoing disputes.
Wider Implications: Leasehold Arrangements and Property Owner Challenges
This case exemplifies the complexities often inherent in Londonโs leasehold property arrangements. Conflicts between leaseholders and leaseholders-of-leaseholders over rights, renovations, and maintenance are not uncommon, especially in premium real estate markets with historical ownership layers.
Dr. Catherine McGuinness, Chair of the City Property Committee, commented: โLeasehold disputes can be protracted and costly, often stemming from ambiguous rights over modifications and repairs. The Park Lane case highlights the importance of clear agreements and the potential for even high-value properties to become embroiled in longstanding legal battles.โ
Outlook: An Uncertain Resolution
With the dispute ongoing into its ninth year and both parties maintaining firm legal positions, the eventual resolution remains unclear. Court proceedings continue, and neither side has indicated readiness to compromise.
Representatives for the Hodsons, the Al Fayed estate, Prestige Properties, and the Grosvenor Estate all declined to comment on the details of the case when approached by the BBC.
For now, the legal battle casting a shadow over one of Londonโs most prestigious properties appears emblematic of the challenges facing legacy property empires and the complexities of urban leasehold ownership.
For more detailed analysis and ongoing coverage of US labor markets, trade policies, UK government, finances and markets stay tuned toย ย PGN Business Insider.
