A cross-party committee of UK MPs has criticised the Home Office for lacking reliable data on whether foreign workers on skilled worker visas leave the country on time or remain illegally after their visas expire. The Public Accounts Committee (PAC), responsible for scrutinising government expenditure, said the Home Office had not adequately analysed exit checks since the new skilled worker visa route was introduced in December 2020, raising concerns about immigration control and worker exploitation.
Skilled Worker Visa Exit Monitoring Inadequate
The skilled worker visa route, which replaced the Tier 2 (General) work visa following the UKโs departure from the European Union, aims to attract high-skilled foreign workers to address labour shortages in sectors such as health and social care. Since its launch, the Home Office has received approximately 1.18 million applications through this channel up to the end of 2024, making it a central element of the UKโs post-Brexit immigration policy.
However, the latest PAC report reveals serious shortcomings in the systemโs ability to track whether visa holders exit the UK upon completion of their permitted work period. According to the committeeโs findings, the Home Office continues to rely primarily on airline passenger data to monitor departures, but has failed to analyse these records in any meaningful way since 2020.
โThe department has shown little curiosity about how the route was operating, missing basic information on whether visa holders left the country or overstayed,โ the report states. The PAC has urged the Home Office to implement robust measures that record when individuals leave the UK and thus ensure proper immigration enforcement.
Exploitation and Worker Welfare Concerns
Beyond the administrative gaps, the committeeโs report highlights widespread evidence of labour abuses linked to the skilled worker visa scheme. It notes significant cases of workers suffering from โdebt bondage,โ excessive working hours, and exploitative conditions issues acknowledged as endemic problems within certain sectors reliant on foreign labour.
The report criticises the Home Officeโs response to exploitation concerns as โslow and ineffective,โ calling for stronger regulatory oversight and protections. This adds pressure on policymakers to balance the urgent need for skilled workers against safeguarding their rights and well-being.
Government Response and Policy Adjustments
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper acknowledged the reportโs key conclusions during a BBC Breakfast interview, admitting that โthe system hasnโt been strong enoughโ in tracking visa compliance and preventing exploitation. She confirmed that reforms were underway but cautioned that โchange doesnโt happen at the flick of a switch.โ
Cooper outlined current and forthcoming measures designed to improve monitoring and enforcement, including plans to introduce biometric workplace checks based on fingerprint scanning. These would verify that individuals are legally authorised to work, aiming to reduce the risk of illegal employment and overstaying. She also referenced the recent government decision to end overseas recruitment of care workers, part of broader efforts to curb near-record net migration levels.
Commenting on enforcement challenges, the Home Office Permanent Secretary Dame Antonia Romeo described visa overstaying as โa problemโ the department is actively โfixing,โ signalling a commitment to addressing systemic weaknesses.
Expert Perspectives Highlight Transparency and Effectiveness Challenges
Dr Madeleine Sumption, director of the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford, noted on BBC Radio 4โs Today programme that the Home Office had not demonstrated strong transparency or clear evidence of effective interventions to manage visa overstays. She observed, โtheir process so far doesnโt seem to have been hugely effective,โ and suggested the issue would remain a prominent challenge for the department.
These concerns underscore the difficulty facing the Home Office as it seeks to reconcile immigration control with the economic necessity of attracting skilled foreign workers amid ongoing labour shortages.
Immigration Policy Since Brexit
The skilled worker visa system was introduced in the wake of Brexit to create a points-based immigration framework that treats EU and non-EU citizens equally. Its expansion in 2022 was largely aimed at alleviating critical staff shortages in health and social care sectors exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic. This policy shift coincided with a rise in net migration, which reached near-record levels in 2023, fuelled predominantly by skilled worker inflows.
While the government stresses that attracting high-skilled workers supports economic growth and fills essential vacancies, critics highlight that insufficient oversight risks driving illegal stays and exploitation, thereby undermining public confidence in immigration controls.
Looking Ahead: Reforming the Immigration System
A Home Office spokesperson reiterated the governmentโs position, attributing the recent immigration rise partly to โthe previous governmentโs decision five years ago to relax visa controls on skilled workers.โ The department emphasized its ongoing efforts to โfix the broken immigration system,โ including suspending numerous skilled worker sponsor licences, raising qualification thresholds, and eliminating overseas recruitment for certain sectors.
The spokesperson added, โWith our Immigration Whitepaper, we will deliver lower net migration, higher skills, backing British workers and repairing the publicโs trust.โ
Policy analysts anticipate that future reforms will focus heavily on improving data collection, strengthening exit monitoring mechanisms, and enforcing employer compliance. The integration of biometric technologies and enhanced cross-agency cooperation are considered vital steps toward modernising immigration enforcement.
Conclusion
The Public Accounts Committeeโs report reveals critical deficits in the UK governmentโs management of the skilled worker visa route, highlighting a lack of accurate exit data and insufficient action against labour exploitation. As net migration remains a politically sensitive issue, the Home Office faces substantial pressure to bolster oversight systems, increase transparency, and restore public confidence. Achieving these objectives will require sustained commitment amid complex economic and social challenges tied to the UKโs evolving post-Brexit immigration landscape.
Key Statistics:
โ 1.18 million skilled worker visa applications between December 2020 and end of 2024
โ Near record net migration levels recorded in 2023
โ Suspension of highest total of skilled worker sponsor licences since 2012
For more business News, checkย PGN Business Insider.
