A newly emerged band called The Velvet Sundown has attracted over 850,000 monthly listeners on Spotify within weeks of its debut, yet its origins remain mysterious. The group, whose four named members have no public profiles or live performances, faces widespread speculation over whether its music is entirely crafted by artificial intelligence (AI), raising urgent questions about the future of creativity, copyright, and digital authenticity in the music industry.
Spotify Sensation Without a Trace
Since appearing on Spotify several weeks ago, The Velvet Sundownโs indie ballads have been streamed hundreds of thousands of times, quickly garnering significant attention. The bandโs verified Spotify page boasts more than 850,000 monthly listeners, a remarkable feat for a previously unknown act. However, attempts to learn more about the musicians, none of whom have given interviews, appeared on social media, or performed live, have been unsuccessful.
This absence of public-facing identities or traditional promotional activity has led to growing doubts over whether The Velvet Sundown is a conventional band. Critics and listeners have questioned whether AI technologies generate the music wholly or partially. The band denies such claims on social media but has yet to engage directly with journalists seeking comment. A BBC request for an interview went unanswered.
Confusing Clues and the Role of AI
The puzzle deepened following a report from Rolling Stone US that cited a band spokesman admitting The Velvet Sundownโs tracks were created using an AI tool called Suno. Shortly thereafter, the magazine revealed that the spokesman, who identified himself as Andrew Frelon, was a fabricated persona designed as part of a deliberate hoax.
The bandโs official Spotify statement clarified the situation: โThe group has no affiliation with this individual, nor any evidence confirming their identity or existence.โ Further, a purported official account on X (formerly Twitter) linked to the band was also exposed as fake.
Professor Gina Neff, a sociologist specializing in technology and democracy at the University of Cambridgeโs Minderoo Centre, emphasizes the broader implications of the episode. โWhether this is an AI band may not seem important,โ she told the BBC, โbut increasingly, our collective grip on reality seems shaky. The Velvet Sundown story plays into the fears we have of losing control of AI and shows how important protecting online information is.โ
Sound and Style: Human or Machine?
Musically, The Velvet Sundownโs work features guitar-driven indie ballads with male vocals, delivering lyrics such as โeyes like film in faded light, dreams walk barefoot into the nightโ and โash and velvet, smoke and flame, calling out in freedomโs name.โ While the songs are accessible and melodic, critics describe them as somewhat bland, arguably emblematic of early AI attempts to replicate human artistry.
Deezer, a competing streaming platform, has reportedly employed an AI detection tool that classified The Velvet Sundownโs music as โ100% AI generated.โ Spotify, meanwhile, has not publicly commented on the specific case. However, CEO Daniel Ek indicated that while AI-generated music will not be banned from the platform, he opposes using such technologies to imitate existing artistsโ works, reflecting ongoing ethical complexities.
The Industry Struggles Over AIโs Role in Music
Musicians and industry bodies worldwide remain deeply concerned about AIโs growing footprint in music creation. The use of AI tools trained on vast catalogs of existing songs without explicit consent has sparked a backlash from artists who fear their work is being appropriated and devalued.
High-profile figures such as Sir Elton John and Dua Lipa have joined forces with UK House of Lords members to campaign for the government to introduce stronger copyright protections that address AIโs impact on creative industries. Recent legislative attempts fell short despite their efforts, though a separate government consultation on AI and copyright law is ongoing.
Ed Newton-Rex, founder of Fairly Trained โ an organization advocating for creatorsโ rights in the AI age โ pointed to The Velvet Sundown as a real-world example of the problems musicians worry about. โThis is exactly what artists have been worried about: itโs theft dressed up as competition,โ he said. โAI companies steal artistsโ work to build their products, then flood the market with knock-offs, meaning less money goes to human musicians.โ
Sophie Jones, chief strategy officer at the British Phonographic Industry (BPI), echoed these concerns. โThis discussion reinforces many of the concerns raised by the music industry and artist community in recent months on the critical issues of AI and music rights,โ she said, highlighting the urgent need for regulatory clarity.
The Challenge of Verifying Authenticity Online
The Velvet Sundown controversy illustrates a growing challenge in digital culture: verifying authenticity amid increasing AI sophistication and disinformation. When entire creative outputs can be manufactured or manipulated by algorithms, traditional markers of artistic legitimacyโsuch as interviews, social media presence, and live appearancesโmay no longer suffice.
โNew AI technologies blur boundaries between human and machine-made art, complicating how audiences relate to culture and creators,โ Professor Neff observes. She warns that such issues threaten the wider information ecosystem beyond music, impacting trust and shared understanding in society.
Whatโs Next for AI and Music?
As AI-generated content becomes more widespread, the music industry faces a crossroads. Platforms like Spotify must balance embracing innovation with protecting artistsโ rights and preserving creative integrity. Governments and regulators worldwide are under increasing pressure to develop frameworks that address copyright in the AI era, ensuring fair compensation and transparency.
Meanwhile, consumers may need to adapt to an environment where some music they enjoy derives partly or wholly from AI. Whether this raises artistic value or erodes remains a matter of debate.
The Velvet Sundown saga underscores these tensions in stark relief. With its mystique and unanswered questions, the band is a proxy battleground for discussions that will shape the future of music and culture in the digital age.
For more business News, checkย PGN Business Insider.
